Yes men and women can be friends. No it doesn’t mean there’s anything more than friendship between them. Grow up. We’re not in high school, people.
— Unknown
Observed each year on November 19, International Men’s Day (IMD) celebrates the positive value men bring to the world, their families, and communities. It also highlights positive role models and raises awareness of men’s health and well-being. I shared two blog posts for IMD last year, From Joe 90 to Marty: Celebrating the Boy I Was and the Man I Would Become and You’ll Never Walk Alone (Walking Alone). This year’s theme is “The Future Is Everyone” highlighting one of IMD’s six core pillars, to improve gender relations and promote gender equality. I’m taking the opportunity to explore friendship and connection from the perspective of a man whose circle of friends has always included many more women than men.
It’s hard to gauge how common this is. In a 2021 YouGov study on friendship and gender just over half (51%) of British men said that most of their friends were male, suggesting 49% have at least as many women friends as men. Two thirds of British women said the majority of their friends were female. Statistics vary, however. A 2026 survey into the friendships, dating habits, and social lives of young men in the US found that six in ten single men between the ages of eighteen and thirty-five had no female friends at all.
The idea that men and women might struggle to communicate with each other has a long history. John Gray’s 1992 bestseller Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus described men and women as so fundamentally different that we might as well be alien species. That’s not quite as negative as it might seem. The book suggests ways that each species might come to better understand and appreciate the other. Mutual respect and understanding is fundamental to relationships of all kinds. Gray’s advice to women — “Get the love you deserve and [give] your partner the love and support he deserves” — finds an echo in a maxim of Fran’s which we quote in our book. “Give people what they need,” she suggests. “Not what you need to give them.” It’s a reminder I’ve found helpful on many occasions. Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus nonetheless reinforces the idea that men and women are sufficiently different that connecting effectively requires constant effort. I’ve never found that to be the case.
I can’t imagine my life without the women who have been, and continue to be, such a vital part of it. They’ve helped shape who I am and how I relate to myself and others. It’s worth exploring how this came to be, because it wasn’t always so. I attended a boys only school from age eleven until I left home at eighteen. As I’ve written elsewhere, I began university with negligible experience of women or what it meant to be in any kind of relationship. I’d never had a girlfriend and had no female friends. For the next four years I lived in male halls of residence and shared rented accommodation with male friends. Increasingly, though, the meaningful connections I made were with women. This continued after I graduated and moved to London. I retained a few close men friends but without realising it I’d reached a tipping point.
The key factor was the nature of the friendships themselves. I found, and continue to find, women far more open to conversations of the kind meaningful to me, from trivial to serious and all points in between. Many of my women friends — I have several in mind as I write this — have challenged my often limited views and perspectives, opening me to new ideas. These days, my circle of friends is comprised exclusively of women. These are the people I know and trust the most. The people I feel safest with. The people who trust me and feel safe with me. The people I turn to first when something good happens or something bad happens. This is Team Marty and I would be nowhere without them.
I called it my circle of friends but the shape of my support network has also changed over the years. The “inner circle vs. everyone else” model I once cherished grew toxic and I moved to a far more open model in which people were free to enter or exit my world without the requirement to qualify for privileged status. As I describe in Dissolving the Circle:
In my world now there is no Inner Circle: just me and — everybody else! Of course, some people are closer to me than others, some relationships are stronger than others, but there is no circle, no event horizon. It’s been a revelation. Everything is dynamic, rich, colourful. And I feel free. I am free.
This ultimately developed into the model I described a few years ago in Spokesfriends and Insular Groups: What Kind of Support Network Do You Have? In passing, the term “circle of friends” evokes fond memories of one friend who introduced me to the song Circle by American singer-songwriter Edie Brickell. (Hi, Sorcha!)
The value of mixed-gender friendships is well recognised. Leo Tolstoy, author of War and Peace, asserted that, “Nothing is so necessary for a young man as the company of intelligent women.” American educator and feminist Anna Garlin Spencer also proclaimed their benefits whilst striking a note of caution.
The friendship between a man and a woman which does not lead to marriage or desire for marriage may be a life long experience of the greatest value to themselves and to all their circle of acquaintance and of activity; but for this type of friendship both a rare man and a rare woman are needed.
Other commentators have been less enthusiastic. According to Oscar Wilde, “Between men and women there is no friendship possible. There is passion, enmity, worship, love, but no friendship.” To fantasy author Joe Abercrombie, “A friendship between a man and a woman was what you called it when one had been pursuing the other for a long time and never gotten anywhere.” Abercrombie strikes a sour note but voices the common concern that platonic relationships between the sexes are doomed to failure, or at the very least must be guarded against descent into lust and desire. In the words of romance novelist Rachel Robinson, “Male and female friends are always only just-the-tip away from being more.”
This tension was explored to dramatic effect in the 1989 romantic comedy When Harry Met Sally, in which the character of Harry Burns asserts that men and women can’t be friends, “because the sex part always gets in the way.” The movie’s writer Nora Ephron takes this further. “The truth,” she claims, “is that men don’t want to be friends with women. Men know they don’t understand women, and they don’t much care. They want women as lovers, as wives, as mothers, but they’re not really interested in them as friends. They have friends. Men are their friends. And they talk to their male friends about sports, and I have no idea what else.”
The movie has some great lines and memorable performances from Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan. I’ve watched it many times but my experience gives lie to its founding premise. I have no male friends to speak to, and wouldn’t waste my time talking about sports if I did. Not only is friendship between men and women possible, it’s essential. Thankfully, I’m not alone in believing this. The YouGov study I mentioned earlier found that “eight in ten Britons think that (heterosexual) men and women can be just friends, while just 6% think they cannot, and this view is shared by both men and women.”
That’s not to say that things have always been easy for me and my women friends. Nora Ephron would have been closer to the truth (and When Harry Met Sally correspondingly less funny) if she’d written Harry’s line differently. Not always, but sometimes. The sex part sometimes gets in the way. Not necessarily sex, but something more than a platonic friendship. The kind of more about which Ally Barron sang in her 2017 song Just Friends.
Oh, we’re just friends, it’s just not right
I’ll just wait ’til the moment’s right
’Cause you’re just you, and I’m just me
I’m just wishin’ that we could be
Just a little more than this
Just a little more than just friends.
At times there really was more, but not always. There are women I’ve confused and alarmed over the years by my over-attentiveness, clumsiness, and disregard of boundaries. There are hints of this toomuchness in the poetry of my early twenties.
Mothly,
how i ache to understand you,
neither comfort nor console
but holdyou .then a fiercer
flame repels: the memory of
another that my flutterings
confused (an age too long ago.
— from “Mothly”
i feel i’ve found a newfriend
in you .someone to think fondly of
speak fondly to, afraid though i
might hurt you (like the rest)
by coming on too strong
— from “untitled three”
Not that the misreadings were always on my part. As Anna Spencer said, “for this type of friendship both a rare man and a rare woman are needed.” That doesn’t excuse my behaviour, of course. It falls to each of us to be the best person — the best friend — we can be and that means facing up to times when we fall short. In Communicate or Hide? The Creative Dilemma I discussed my past fiction writing and such light as it might shed on my own nature.
There are only two characters I identify with to any great extent. The first is Malcolm, the confused and largely inadequate antihero of “Playing at Darkness.” The second is dour widower William (Bill) Stokes in “And Men Myrtles.” It’s neither easy nor straightforward for me to admit this. I’m fond of Malcolm and Bill, and the stories in which they appear represent the best fiction I’ve ever written. Nevertheless, there are aspects of their personalities and behaviour that I strongly disavow. In these and other tales there are instances of sexism, classism, obsession, inappropriate behaviour, and aggression. Some of these are fundamental to the narrative, others arguably less so. They sit uneasily with me now precisely because I recognise echoes in my own nature, behaviour, and experience in the past.
Writing in 2017 about healthy boundaries, I elaborated on what it meant for me to abandon my old inner circle model.
This meant setting aside lists and categories. It meant not labelling people (“Special People,” “Friends,” “Colleagues,” “Neighbours” etc), and opening my heart to experiencing people for who they are, and my relationships for whatever they might be in the moment. It meant letting go of prior expectations of what a “friendship” (for example) should or needed to be.
Not all relationships are healthy, however. I have had to acknowledge the concept of toxic relationships: not as a label of judgement/blame, but as a valuable descriptor. This has been hard, not least because I have far more examples of me being toxic to others than of others being toxic to me.
That passage demonstrates my use of the word relationship as an umbrella term for the connection between people, regardless of its nature. To me, the connection between friends is a (kind of) relationship; as is that between a parent and their child; or between siblings, colleagues, spouses, lovers, or romantic partners. A quick search suggests that the word first appeared in written English in the seventeenth century where it meant the “sense of being related, by kindred, affinity, or other alliance.” This shifted in the 1940s to specify romantic or sexual intimacy. From the 1970s it broadened to include “all types of enduring social and emotional ties between people.” It’s in this last sense that I’ve always used it, but in so doing I’ve alarmed at least one friend in the past. They insisted I abandon talk of our “relationship” altogether, referring to it solely as a friendship or connection. The words we use matter and I take responsibility for those I choose. I’ve been careful not to make the same mistake since.
Important though it was, that wasn’t the first or only thing I’ve learned from and with my women friends. A full list is beyond the scope of this discussion but they include learning to hold space, to listen, to hear, and to believe. To understand that women’s experience of the world can be very different from a man’s. (Yes, the opposite is also true.) To appreciate, as much as is possible by someone who has not personally experienced them, the realities and consequences of rape, abuse, discrimination, and misogyny. Mental illness, suicidality, and self-harm. How to be there, when not to be, and how to let go.
I’ve also learned a great deal about what being a man means to me, and what it can mean to others. I’ve shared some of this previously here, in such posts as Being a Man: Exploring My Gender Identity, Big Boys Cry Too: Challenging Toxic Masculinity, and THIS BOY GETS SAD TOO.
In our book High Tide, Low Tide: The Caring Friend’s Guide to Bipolar Disorder I pay tribute to my closest and deepest friendship of all.
I am a better person for knowing Fran. I have a greater understanding of my strengths, values, weaknesses, and vulnerabilities than ever before. I have learned more about mental and invisible illness, suicidal thinking, stigma, determination, courage, and responsibility since we became friends than in the fifty years before we met. I have explored meditation, Non-violent Communication (NVC), mindfulness, and other techniques that benefit my life enormously.
I have greatly expanded my circle of friends, met people who feel safe sharing their stories in response to mine, and learned how it feels to offer my skills and experience in the service of others. I have grown — and continue to grow — as a friend and as a man. But the most important thing I have gained is our friendship itself. Why do I do it? Because Fran is my best friend and that is what best friends do.
There’s a lot still to learn but I’m reassured by some of the things my friends tell me that I’m on the right track. In the course of writing this blog post Fran commented that I always have something of wisdom to contribute in our conversations, no matter what she’s going through or dealing with. I was thanked recently for being a steadfast friend, recalling another friend years ago who said I was someone she could rely on “in an emergency and at all other times.” One of my favourite accolades came a few years ago by a friend who told me “You’re good at supporting without being a prat.” I treasure that one above diamonds! (Hi, Jen!)
I’ll close with something someone said to me when we were newly friends. There’s an ache in sharing it because we are no longer in each other’s lives, but the wisdom is as valid today as it was sincere at the time. “Nobody said friendships were easy but when you find that right friend it’s worth it.”
Illustration by Bayram Bilici at Unsplash.

Comments
Post a Comment